Choosing a sperm donor: 6 considerations

Gaia Team
A team of people deeply invested in fertility science and technology
In this guide

Summary

  • Sperm banks allow you to choose a donor with qualities you want. Some people choose sperm donors with similar complexions, backgrounds, or personalities to their own so that their child will bear a resemblance to them.
  • Sperm is sold in vials, and many people will need multiple vials to conceive a child. 
  • Some donors want to be anonymous, so you and your child won’t be able to contact them. Others are open to sharing contact information after your child turns 18.
  • If you’re planning to have more than one child, your children can be genetically related if you decide to use the same donor’s sperm.

There are many reasons you may decide to have a baby with donor sperm. Women without a male partner, same sex-female couples, male factor infertility, or maybe even to avoid passing on a genetic disorder. 

While being able to hand-pick your donor is exciting, it can be intimidating, too. So, how do you choose a sperm donor? We’re here to help with a guide so that you can make an informed decision, understand the selection process, and consider all of the factors. Here are 6 things to think about before choosing a sperm donor: 

How to choose a sperm donor

Sperm donor arrangement

Donors in the US can be anonymous, open to sharing information later, or a “known donor,” like a friend or family member. You can source sperm through a reputable sperm bank or from someone you know — although choosing a “known donor” isn’t necessarily easier, as they will have to adhere to the FDA requirements and quarantine periods required for anonymous donation.

Choosing the right sperm bank

Picking a sperm bank can be daunting. Your fertility clinic will likely have a list of recommended banks to help narrow your search. Most sperm banks in the United States have very strict criteria for their donors, and it may be worthwhile to check their licenses and accreditations.  This is where you can be picky!

Check the legislation in your state

The United States has implemented universal laws regarding sperm donation across all states. This means that all men who donate sperm are required to have the same blood tests and physical screening process, with a six month quarantine of samples followed by retesting. However, it is important to discuss specific state laws around contractual agreements with your doctor.

Picking a known donor may feel more comfortable for you, but it does not expedite the screening and quarantine process in most cases. Most clinics also require psychological evaluations for both parties to be sure everyone understands their role after your child is born. An adoption attorney or a family law lawyer can help you understand the nuances of the law in your area.

Sperm donor characteristics

One of the most appealing parts of using a sperm donor is being able to select someone based on characteristics that are important to you.

Physical characteristics: You’ll be able to review a donor’s height and weight, their hair color and texture, their eye color, and their ethnic background. Many sperm banks offer photos of the donor as a child and as an adult, and you will have the ability to select your preferences. 

You can be as specific as you want, picking hair and eye color, height, weight, athleticism, education, and much more. Keep in mind that the more specific you get, the harder it will be to find an exact match.

Cost of donor sperm

Donor sperm is sold in vials, each containing millions of sperm! Most clinics recommend purchasing 2 vials per treatment, whether it is being used for IUI or IVF, but you may choose to buy more if you wish to have multiple children. Your clinic can help you navigate these decisions! 

Depending on the donor, clinic, and your location, donor sperm can cost anywhere from $400-2,500 per vial. 

Quick plug: Gaia is the most affordable way to start and protect your IVF treatment, and a Gaia Plan can cover IVF with donor sperm. If you’re interested in a personalized, no-pressure quote, request a quote or learn how it works. 

Having multiple children with the same donor’s sperm 

If you’re planning to have more than one child, some people pre-pay for several vials from the same donor so that their children are genetically related. Because sperm banks can run out of a specific donor’s sperm over time, it’s smart to set aside money for more vials or to pre-pay and reserve your sperm. Some sperm banks offer “buy back” partial reimbursement programs if you pre-pay for sperm and ultimately decide not to use it. 

If you’re considering having multiple children, ask your clinic if they have a “sibling inventory” or “sibling stock” option, which sets sperm vials aside for people who want to have biologically related children from the same donor. 

Summary

On top of a fair and affordable way to pay for fertility treatments like IVF with donor sperm, Gaia has a team of experts and a supportive community to help guide you through your IVF journey. If you need recommendations or help to start your path toward parenthood, we can recommend a clinic near you and personalize you a quote to finance your IVF treatment.

Written by
Gaia Team
The Gaia team is made up of people deeply invested in fertility science and technology. They work directly with medical experts to bring you accurate and actionable information to help people on their own IVF journeys. Many team members have gone through fertility treatment and understand just how personal, challenging, and rewarding the journey can be.

How can Gaia help?

A Gaia Plan is the most affordable way to start and protect your IVF.
Start your IVF with fixed costs that you only pay once you have a child.

How the Gaia plan works

Learn more about fertility

Join our community

So far I am very happy with Gaia
So far I am very happy with Gaia, I am about to have my first try of IVF with them, I have found them extremely helpful and all the staff I have delt with have been so kind and friendly. I would recommend using Gaia.

Laura

Published 2 Oct 2023
Gaia makes the world a happier place
Gaia are so friendly, welcoming and kind! We were so so excited to hear about Gaia when we attended a open evening at Bourn Hall Wickford. It is the most amazing gift that Gaia can give to a person/persons, they put fertility treatment...

Mrs Sarah Prince

Published 17 sep 2023
Gaia is my family too!!!
I haven't started my treatment yet but till this point I'm very happy with Gaia family. I don't have words to express my gratitude and I'm sure with their help I will have my baby soon. The communication have been excell...

Gabriella

Published 8 jul 2023
Reviews from:
We and selected partners, use cookies or similar technologies as specified in the cookie policy.

Nice to see you.

Ready to get to know us?

Head over to our UK site.

We’re on our way to your state

Find out more about our expansion throughout the US.

We can’t wait to meet you.